Demon’s Souls Remake Debates Continue
Demon’s Souls Remake, one of the PlayStation 5’s launch titles, remains a source of controversy even after five years. While FromSoftware fans argue that Bluepoint Games’ remake fails to preserve the spirit of the original, some players believe the new version is technically superior. The debate has reignited on social media.
Demon’s Souls Remake Is Being Debated Among Fans
The debate was sparked by a post by X (Twitter) user elbethium, which read, “The remake is better than the original in every way.” This bold comment quickly garnered thousands of replies, sparking a renewed “original vs. remake” war within the FromSoftware community. While many fans acknowledge Bluepoint’s technical excellence, they argue that the atmosphere and dark art style have lost the original’s “soul.”
Many players are complaining that everything in the remake, from the enemy designs to the environmental color palette, is “too clean” and “too bright.” The redesign of the Fat Official character has become a frequent example for fans. They say the disturbing atmosphere FromSoftware created in the first game has been replaced by a sterile aesthetic in the remake.
On the other hand, there are those who defend the remake. This group believes that Bluepoint modernized the game’s technical infrastructure, making it accessible to a new generation of players. They also argue that it offers an experience far surpassing the original in terms of performance, lighting, and sound design. They consider both versions to be “perfect” in their time.
Demon’s Souls Remake was released at the end of 2020 as one of the PS5’s launch titles and received high critical acclaim. However, even five years later, it remains one of the most concrete examples of the question “What is more important? Technical mastery or atmospheric fidelity?” in the gaming world. It seems the Demon’s Souls debate will continue within the FromSoftware community for many years to come.
Read More: Horizon Zero Dawn Film Revealed Through Court Documents
