Tales of the Shire Fails with Critics
The Lord of the Rings universe once inspired exciting projects in the gaming world. However, in recent years, things seem to have taken a turn for the worse. After unforgettable titles like Shadow of Mordor and Shadow of War, license-based games have been failing to deliver. Tales of the Shire is the latest example. While the idea of a tranquil life simulation set in the Shire sounded appealing at first glance, critics’ reviews have fallen far short of expectations.
Why Did Tales of the Shire Fail?
Tales of the Shire: A The Lord of the Rings Game is now officially released. Initial reviews for the game are disappointing. According to Metacritic, the PC version has a score of 60/100. Despite only six reviews, the PlayStation 5 version has a rather low score of 54/100, placing it among the lowest-ranking Lord of the Rings games released to date.
In Metacritic’s ranking of Lord of the Rings games, Tales of the Shire ranks 19th out of 25. Based on the PS5 version’s score, this rank drops to 24th. This places Tales of the Shire just above the recent releases of Return to Moria and the highly disappointing Gollum game.
The game originally promised to offer a peaceful life in place of aggressive conflict. It offered players experiences like tending to farms in the Shire, interacting with neighbors, and exploring Hobbit life. However, this slow-paced and simplistic structure was criticized by many critics as lacking in content and lacking in mechanics.
While the innovative Nemesis system introduced in Shadow of Mordor is still talked about, the waste of such potential in a universe with mundane projects is disappointing fans. Tales of the Shire may appeal to a certain audience with its relaxing gameplay, but overall, it falls short of the quality and richness of content a licensed game should possess. There is still hope for the Lord of the Rings universe; but this hope was once again postponed with Tales of the Shire.
Read More: WB Games Montréal Working on New DC Live-Service Game
